The Four Corners Branch of the Brampton Public Library is the branch that I have always used. It is located in the downtown area of Brampton, just off of one of the major streets, and backs onto one of the oldest residential areas of Brampton.
In the neighbourhood there is an elementary and secondary school, a retirement home, the local theatre, and a park all within a five minute walk from the library.
One of the first things I noticed was a single sign on a wooden fence that could easily missed. The sign indicated that there was parking here for the Library. As you can see in the image below the sign says, “Brampton Public Library” which is no longer the name of the library; the current library in Brampton is called the Brampton Library. In addition, the logo in the bottom right of the image that is also outdated.
When you turn into the library parking lot, I notice the small amount of parking that is available. There are only enough parking spaces available for less than 20 cars. There are only two signs on this side of the building, one is a warning sign that is almost completely faded, but it does say “NUTECH Secutirty”. On the other sign it says “Additional Library Parking off John St.” with an arrow. The main parking lot I am in is supposed to be a one way parking lot.
The image below is my map of where this branch is located and where the library parking lot is in relation to the building and access to those lots. If you go the proper way through the main parking lot, you will end on Queen Street, which does not directly go to John Street. If you return to the one way street that I came off of, and continue to the stop sign and turn left, it will lead you to the extra parking lot which holds less than 30 additional vehicles. I did not see any available bike or skateboard stations in either the main parking lot or the secondary parking lot which may be an indication that people using this library prefer to walk or drive. Another possibility is that the bike and/or skateboard lock stations are covered in snow.
From the secondary parking lot, you can see the loading dock and the children’s area on the first floor, and desks facing the parking lot on the second floor. From this parking lot, patrons must walk through the long outdoor corridor to the second entrance in the front. In the image below you can see the long outdoor corridor from the secondary parking lot on the right of the image.
I was surprised to find that there was not a sign that had an arrow indicating how to get to the main entrance. On this side of the building there was also not an indication that this building was indeed the Four Corners Branch. The only indications that this building was the library (apart from the windows where you can clearly see the children’s department), was signage from John Street indicating that there was parking for the library, and in the parking lot which said the maximum amount of time that could be spent parking there. The signage from the four way stop at John Street has the old logo and library name.
After walking through the outdoor corridor, you are brought to a small set of stairs which lead to a set of doors, with no signage.
If a patron had a difficult time with stairs they would have to go down a small hill around the large Brampton Library Sign and then up to the doors.
The image below is of the large Brampton Library sign which can only been seen from Queen Street next to a road entrance. This road entrance cannot be entered from Queen Street. This sign is the only one outside the building which demonstrates the library’s name change.
When I park in the first parking lot, I walk towards the first set of doors (on the right side of the image below), past a garden with benches around it, and tried to open the locked doors. These doors have windows on them and I can see a small area and another set of doors, which I know from experience is the entrance to the auditorium.
The other set of doors (on the left side of the image above) from this parking lot are open and next to them is a book drop, which is only open after the library closes.
When I walked through these doors directly across is the entrance on the Queen Street side of the branch. On the wall to my left is a wall labelled “Info City” and it is covered in cork boards and clear shelves. This holds general information about Brampton, park and recreation, local theatre booklets, and local business advertisements.
To the right of the entrance is the circulation desk and one book drop spot with books stacking higher than the desk. To the right of the desk, next to the doors are three shelving carts full with videos that have been recently returned. To the left of the circulation desk there are crate like boxes, which I can only guess were the inter-branch currier system boxes. There were probably eight boxes and they were stacked.
I looked around the circulation desk and was surprised to see that there was no signage at all around the desk that indicated it was where you could sign books in and out. There were a couple of people in line waiting to check their books out.
Past the circulation desk, looking at the length of the building, my immediate thought is that it is like a hallway without walls, it is the main aisle on the lower level. I enter the library in the evening and there are approximately 20 people on the lower level. The atmosphere is very quiet, despite that there are children in the children’s department at the back of the library on this lower level.
Past the circulation desk on the left side is the elevator, DVD, CD, and Audio Book area. There was one cart of unshelved materials. The DVD shelves were also messy with DVDs on their side when they are meant to stand upright. This to me is an indication that the collection is well used and browsed.
To the right side of the circulation desk is the auditorium, a staircase, and a photocopier. Next to the staircase are express use computers. These computers can be used to quick use for up to 15 minutes to search the catalogue or use the internet. There was signage for this area, however, the computers were quite high and I am not sure if someone in a wheel chair would be able to access them.
Past the electronic collection (CD, DVD, and Audio Books) is a small shelf, one large shelf, and two shelving carts packed with holds. This is another indication that this a well circulated library. When I went to collect the books I had on hold, I noticed that there were a lot of holds for the same person. I did not inspect further because I felt like that was a violation of privacy and unprofessional.
Along the wall on the left side of the library are the Large Print books and perpendicular to the Large Print books are the Adult General Fiction books. Both sections are organized alphabetically by author. I was disappointed in the amount of room available in the aisle for the Large Print books. I automatically thought about a senior with a walker and I don’t think there would be enough room for them to be comfortable between the aisles. I also noticed that there was not clear indications of what alphabetical books each shelf had.
While I was thinking about aisle sizes, I conducted the “bum” test. The “bum” test is something that I learned from working at Chapters. In training the managers told us that during a study, which videotaped shoppers in retail stores revealed many things about shopping habits. One of the study’s findings was that if a woman shopping bends down to get something from a lower shelf and their bottom touches the shelf behind her, she will immediately leave the aisle. When I tested the aisles, I bent over to look at a book on the bottom shelf in the Adult General Fiction book section, and am proud to say the shelving past the “bum” test.
For the entire duration that I watched the Adult General Fiction book area there were only two people besides myself browsing the shelves. I was surprised not see more people browsing because of the large amount of returns, unshelved returns, and holds. I again looked for signage and there was only 8 1/2 x 11 laminated paper signs with small print on the end caps. These signs indicated the alphabetical range of authors shelved there. The laminated signs said, “Adult Fiction” and “Authors __ __ – __ __”. On almost all the end caps that faced the main aisle were clear plastic shelves for book displays . There were no easily identified display themes, if there were themes at all. On the shelves that were shorter there were shelving carts of books waiting to be shelved; another indication that this library has a good circulation.
On the wall across the main aisle on the opposite wall is the Adult Mystery and Science Fiction books. In front of those books are spinners for the paperback Mysteries, Science Fiction, Westerns, True Crime, and Non-Fiction. In front of the spinners next to the main aisle is seating for nearly 40 people and 8 computers. Most of the computers are being used while I am there and no one is waiting to use them. The available seating is being used by a couple of students, 2 readers, and one family of three.
Just past the Mystery and Science Fiction Section is the Young Adult area. I was disappointed at the size of this section because I love reading Young Adult Fiction. There was a whole shelving cart with Manga in the Teen area which seemed like it was their permanent home. I was pleased that there were spinners that separated the Young Adult material from the large seating area available. I was surprised to find a large Teen display in front of that area. It was complete with a poster created by the library youth group and information pamphlets that could be taken.
In the middle of the main aisle next to the teen area is the Information Desk. This information desk is closer to a circle than any other shape (in other words, it’s a rounded-corner oval) and it is approximately a meter high. There was one person working at the desk at that time but there were two computers; for one person to face the front doors and circulation of the library and the other facing the back of the library towards the children’s department. There are ottomans around the desk for people to sit on while they interact with the librarian on duty. I think these chairs are fantastic because then there can be a relaxed reference interview. The top of the desk is mostly clear there are a couple of binders. On the back side of the information desk, there is a themed display for children. In this display are varying levels of children’s books, relevant toys, posters and images. Again, there is no signage which indicates what the desk is and what the people at the desk do. However, just that there is a desk demonstrate that the people sitting there have a position of power and knowledge.
Just behind the teen area is the Children’s Non-Fiction area and on the opposite side of the main aisle are chapter books on spinners, shelves with children’s audio books, junior chapter books, and computers for children.
The children’s department is clearly indicated with a multi-coloured sign hanging from the ceiling. The children’s reading and play area is sectioned off with shelving for picture books organized alphabetically. The shelving in the children’s department is fantastic, there are two shelves which is about a meter high and then there is a small a frame on top of the shelving. In the children’s area are small seating areas, small tables and chairs. Along the left wall of the children’s area near the Junior Chapter Book shelf are a couple of shelves for materials in other languages, which indicates that there is a very small population of people that speak another language in community this library serves. This is consistent with the information provided by StatsCan.
I then went upstairs to the second floor and immediately noticed the difference between the two floors in terms of atmosphere. The lower level was quiet but it was a more relaxed environment with comfortable seating. The upper level was also very quiet however, the atmosphere was very work oriented. There were approximately 20 tables to the left of the staircase and one third of them were being used mostly for work. On a surrounding wall were magazines and there were a couple of people browsing them which surprised me because the atmosphere was tense and I often associate magazines with a more leisurely ambiance.
Directly across where I emerged from the staircase were these beautiful wooden shelves with glass doors. I had never seen these shelves before and I wasn’t sure what they were for. When I looked around there was signage that indicated that this area was the Local History and Genealogy collection. Although the shelving was beautiful, they had doors on them which immediately made me think that they were closed stacks. These stacks are indexed in a special catalogue accessible only in the library. My overall impression of this collection is that the library is trying to control access to it. I cannot imagine trying to use that collection on my own without a staff member helping me, not because I think I am incapable, but because they have taken measures to control its use. The local history collection should be well used and cherished which cannot be achieved when the space itself suggests that it is an out of bounds collection.
Next to the Local History and Genealogy collection are 20 computers, most of which are being used. I observed patrons using them for games, email, using word processing applications, and searching the internet. Most of the computers were being used by individuals; I only saw one group working around a single computer. There were no line ups and it was very quiet.
To the right of the staircase is the main aisle with the information desk in the middle in front of the collection. This information desk, similar to the lower level of the library is a rounded corner oval with no signage, and ottoman seating around the desk. The placement of this desk is more of a sign of power than the lower level desk because it is in the centre of the main aisle, situated before the stacks began. I think the placement of this desk enforces the librarian stereotype of being “gatekeepers” because you must past the information desk to get to the stacks. The desk is positioned near the reference collection and I think that is both wise and controlling. I think it is wise because some of the books are difficult to use if a patron has never used one before, and librarians will be able to quickly re-shelve materials. On the other hand placing the information desk next to the reference collection is controlling it because it demonstrates that these items need to be returned and cannot be taken out. However, I have seen libraries where the reference collection is directly behind the information desk and can only be accessed with a librarian’s help; at least this is open for people to access the information in their own way.
On the right side of the information desk is a study room and a meeting room. There are also four quick access computers, a display wall, and seating along the right wall of the library.
The stacks behind the librarians on the left wall are for the non-fiction collection organized by the Dewey Decimal System. At the very back of the library is a seating area that faces out to the secondary parking lot. When I entered this area, there were two people working and they both looked up and gave me the “this is a serious workspace”. When I sat down and reflected, I realized that there were no study carrels there was only a study room. After reflecting on the furniture used on this level, I think that the library is trying to make the library a more comfortable and inviting work area. Whereas, the furniture on the lower level invites a more social atmosphere.
Overall, I was really disappointed with the lack of reader’s advisory services. There were several a frames throughout the library though the display themes were unknown, there were no pathfinders available, and no shelf talkers.
I was also disappointed with the lack of signage. I think that anyone that did not understand libraries would be intimidated because they would not understand where to go for what they are looking for.
I was surprised with how quiet the library was; the libraries I worked in had very social atmospheres. The quiet atmosphere may be due to my visit during exam week, though only half of the patrons in the library were students.
I also had expected to see more people browsing the stacks because of the amount of holds, returns, and materials that still needed to be shelved. During my observation, I also did not see any roving reference to my surprise and disappointment. I think roving reference is just as important as is having someone at the circulation and information desk. I also did not see any signs of a community outside the Teen Display, which was again disappointing. There was very little advertising of the services they provide and the only advertisement was their calendar on display on the lower level. This calendar’s placement, I think is placed too closely to the children’s area and is too colourful. The calendar could easily be passed over by someone that does not have children or is uninterested in the children’s services because of it is very colourful and its proximity to the children’s department.
When I identified myself to the librarians, they were all very friendly and interested in what I was doing. I asked to take pictures in the library and the librarians informed me that they had a policy against it. I am looking forward to proposing new ideas to improve the library service at the Four Corners Branch in Brampton.














